
Developed/Published by: Firaxis Games / 2K Games
Released: October 9th, 2012
Completed: 10th December 2015
Completion: Beat it on easy; noodled around in classic ironman.
Trophies / Achievements: 40%
The story goes like this. Round about the time this came out I got it, downloaded it for my PC, and played through the tutorial. Then for whatever reason I needed to reinstall my computer, and I thought “you know what, I really liked what I played of XCOM. I’ll definitely reinstall that and dig into it properly. In fact, I’m excited.”
Anyway, then I didn’t. I got distracted playing other turn-based strategy games like Valkyria Chronicles and designer of the original X-Com Julian Gollop’s own Ghost Recon: Shadow Wars. Plus, I have to admit I probably kept putting it off, waiting for the mythical Vita version. I finally gave up that impossible dream and just decided to play it on PS3, as I was suddenly in the mood for a tactics-me-do.
But here’s the deal! I was so confident that I’d like XCOM: Enemy Unknown after that tutorial taster that I thought I’d still play the original version rather than jumping forward to the slightly expanded version, XCOM: Enemy Within. “I’m sure I’ll want to play it through more than once, so I’ll try vanilla first to see what’s that like.” That’s what I thought.
Honestly, I’ll never play it again. I’ve got no interest in playing through even an expanded version, because it turns out a quick tutorial can’t broadcast that, at least as far as I’m concerned, XCOM: Enemy Unknown is far too slight in both its metagame (you know, the base building and all that) and tactical battles to keep interest for the length of time it takes to get through. And I never want to see the terrible cut-scenes ever again.
(I feel like I get increasingly hardline about stories in games as time passes. Playing XCOM: Enemy Unknown I was struck by how it’s got several characters that just… exist, trying to make the game seem like it’s got a story. Look at the amazing UFOpedia page on Dr. Vahlen, where they struggle to make sense of the fact she’s supposed to be German but her accent is crap. She’s basically a tooltip given a dodgy voice, and it’s a waste of everyone’s time; characters don’t give you something to empathise and connect with just by existing. That you spend the game with a basically faceless squad getting deeply attached to certain members lays this lie bare, which is probably why it annoys me so much here.)
This is a game where I found myself actually annoyed when I had to go on a mission—otherwise known as “the main point of the game”—because I found it so boring (missions are linear, slow to get started, and actively generic.) It’s hard not to compare the game to the aforementioned Ghost Recon: Shadow Wars, a game that has the benefit of a more obviously linear story (well, XCOM: Enemy Unknown pastes that on but I’d imagine you’re supposed to be enjoying the more roguelike-likey Earth defense aspect) so it can have character moments and a variety of intentionally designed missions. I admit to still finding Shadow Wars: Ghost Recon a bit generic, but despite sharing similar tactical battle systems, I could still find myself pulling off impressive manoeuvres in it. In XCOM: Enemy Unknown I felt like it was “move foward slowly, shoot enemies or, if no visible enemies, overwatch” 90% of the time—and that includes when lives are at stake in ironman mode. You play methodically, joylessly. If someone dies, it’s the percentages.
I could rag on the metagame too, at length. It’s poorly explained, depressingly short in progression and largely prescribed via the plot. But the main thing is that XCOM: Enemy Unknown is just deeply, deeply uninspiring. The kind of game you get a good night’s sleep after: I didn’t spend a second wondering how I’d develop my base, how I’d keep my satellites in the sky, or what perk to take next with my squad members. And this is a guy who’d spend hours wondering about what public works project to build next in Animal Crossing: New Leaf. Hours.
Will I ever play it again? Well, I won’t play XCOM: Enemy Within, that’s for sure. But I’m open-minded about XCOM 2, having read a little about it and am interested in the small changes they’ve made. Not totally convinced yet, however.
Final Thought: Now, I know my impression of this game diverges wildly with most folks (you know, like usual) but I really did try with this one. I mean, I know how everyone had an amazing time naming their squad after friends and celebrities, telling tales about how Dot Cotton saved their mate Kevin’s life after Neil Degrasse Tyson missed two 94% sniper shots. I named every single squad member after a player for the national football team of the flag they’d been assigned, and in the end it was Scotland’ Ikechi Anya that gave up his life to save the Earth, and any following World Cups in-universe probably featured most countries having to call up surviving third division players and/or anyone who once kicked a ball, even if it was just by accident while walking. It wasn’t enough to get me over the innate boringness of this game though. Sorry!

