Developed/Published by: Hipster Whale
Released: November 20th, 2014
Completed: 23rd November, 2014
Completion: I got a score of 248 and was like “yeah, good enough.”
Trophies / Achievements: n/a

Crossy Road is really good! I completely, totally recommend that you download it, if you’ve got an iOS or android device or whatever, and play it. It’s completely worth it, what with it being free and that.

Now, that said, down to the business of pulling the game apart, such is the way of this blog.

Shall I start with something basic, like the controls? Yeah, let’s do that. If you’re not au fait with Crossy Road (because you didn’t, just that second when I recommended it, download and play it) it’s an endless Frogger. It’s complete ingenious, in that way that when you see it you’re surprised no one ever thought of it before. In fact, I’m suspicious that someone must have. Seems like the kind of thing there are loads of on the app store, only they’re all ugly and crap, looking like Unity test projects. Maybe not loads. At least a couple (only now I’m sure they’d be impossible to find, as every shitehawk clone merchant starts to pump out Roadie Cross, Angry Bird Cross, Ridiculous 2048 Cross Wings, etc.) 

Anyway, Crossy Road is isometric and lets you tap to move forward, and swipe to move left and right. Can you guess? Yeah, it’s super easy to throw yourself into traffic as you try and adjust your position by a swipe being read as a tap. Super easy, and every time it happens it sucks. A lot.

That’s annoying, but it’s not what made me stop, actually. What made me stop was… well, I’ve been playing TxK, right? (Which is also great, and you should totally get it even though it’s not free at all.) Anyway, some years ago Jeff Minter had the amazing idea (at least, I think it was his idea and I’d rather type this caveat rather than google it) that his games could “save” your highest score as you progressed and let you start again from it when you died. Not in an infinite continues way, but in a “this was your highest score, and this was how many lives you had at the time.” The idea being that rather than having to go through all the boring easy levels again—that you’d probably perfected—you can just start at a point where you know you’ve mastered it and continue from there.

(TxK does over-egg it a bit by giving you a save after every level. I’d prefer a single save at the first level you died, so you could always start from a “perfect” run, but that’s another article entirely.)

Anyway, I was thinking about this because Crossy Road is about, well, getting as far as possible, but that means once you’ve got a sufficiently high score—over about 100, I found—it’s super super annoying to have to do that first 100 moves. Now, Crossy Road doesn’t seem to have a particularly intense difficulty curve (it definitely gets harder, but it’s subtle) so I’d imagine that giving you checkpoints would allow players to easily climb into the thousands, at which point what would be the point? After all, Minter’s save system removes something that can easily be argued as important to old arcade games—the endurance test. You’re not at 100% the whole time, you’re going to lose concentration, or slip due to tiredness. I know, having played in enough 6+ hour Netrunner tournaments (not the same thing, but, you know, educational on endurance, anyway.)

Thing is, that doesn’t remove the fact that once you’ve got a decent score in Crossy Road climbing back up there is just boring. I don’t want to do it. So I don’t.

Will I ever play it again? Nah.

Final Thought: If you want an interesting comparison, however, there’s Canabalt, which I’m happy to play every once in a while because it’s so rhythmic and fast, or perhaps even more comparable there’s Jetpack Joyride, which I played, as the kids say, the shit out of. Crossy Road made some waves for being “indie” but including loads of free-to-play business, and yet it didn’t include any of the stuff from Jetpack Joyride which makes it so compelling (to the point where I rarely cared about my high score) in terms of unlockables that significantly (well, sort of) change the game, and everyone’s favourite, the coin doubler (which I never paid for, but I’m surprised that Crossy Road didn’t ship with it.) 

Anyway, wasn’t the original Frogger endless Frogger? It was just cut up into levels rather than one long experience. Really makes you think, huh.